1 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The following people have been of enormous value to the Panel and we would like to thank them all for their help, support and advice during the Review period: Imogen Anderson, Research Michael Garrad, BBC Governance Unit Alex Gilletti Sinead Toner, BBC Information Chris Westcott, Director, BBC Monitoring Mohamed El-Doufani, BBC Monitoring Chris Banatvala, Ofcom Professor Sir Nigel Rodley, Human Rights Centre, Essex University Noam Lubell, Essex University Professor Sir Lawrence Freedman, Dept of War Studies, King’s College London Professor Frederick Halliday, International Relations Department, LSE Dr George Joffe, Centre of International Studies, Cambridge Dr Neill Lochery, Dept of Hebrew & Jewish Studies, University College London Dr Beverley Milton-Edwards, School of Politics, International Studies and Philosophy, Queen's University Belfast